Good morning, class. How're you doing? Hope it's great! Finished with your PKn subject/ civics, eh?
Well, today, for session 1, let's watch a strange video of a man and a train as a MEANS of transport. Please do not do this.
Well, what do you think of the video clip?
1. Discuss with friend(s) what happenED. Around 30 words
Discuss via WA, Line, WeChat or Google Meet.
2. Is it real ? Tell me your reason. 20 words.
3. Who do you think he is? A superhero/ a mutant? 15 words.
4. How was the clip made? 35 words.
Write your whatsapp chat/ Google meet discussion result with friends in around 100 words in total.
Write your names (1 reply is enough for thebtwo of you).
Deadline: 10:50am.
19 comments:
Names: EUNIKE STELLIA LEE 8B/8 and WILLIAM WIJAYA 8B/27
1. In the video, the train was coming and it was honking its horn when suddenly a man appeared. When the train got near the man, he suddenly kicked the train and it went in the opposite direction.
2. No, it isn’t. In our opinion, the video is just edited buy the creator of the video.
3. In our opinion, he is just a normal human being. He just has good skills in editing.
4. First, he recorded a clip when the train was coming towards him. Second, he recorded a clip when the man was kicking. Third, he recorded a clip when the train was going away from the man. Lastly, he edited those three clips together to make one video.
We think that it is fake because there is no way that a human can do that. We think it is edited. The video could be made with the train moving first and the person walked up from behind it and kicked it. And they reverse the footage of the video so it would look like the train is coming towards him and he kicked it.
By Henri 8B/12 ; Willy 8B/28
Names : Natania A C 8B/18 and Chika 8B/6
1. in our opinion, the video was edited. So when the train comes the person comes to the railroad tracks and kicks his legs, then after the train has passed the person moves his feet again like he was kicking the train.
2. In our opinion, it's not real because I don't if there are people in this world who have that kind of power.
3. in our opinion, He is just a normal human and has no super power.
4.the clip was made by editing and agility of people who are on the railroad tracks. And people on the railroad tracks must be brave and fast so they don't get hit
Name : Felicia.A.l 8B/9 and Judith.G.W 8B/16
1. what happens in the video is that the man stands in the middle of the railroad tracks and kicks the train when the train is approaching the guy there
2. in my opinion this is not real because no one can kick the train and the train goes straight away
3.We think as our opinion he is a normal human being,but he has change the video using editing.
4.First he recorded the video when the train come to him.Then,he stopped the train.He recorded the video again when the train going away.Last he adited the video.
Names : Darren Christopher 8B/07 and Jonathan Reyes Wiganda 8B/13
1.The video is about a train that about to ram a guy so they honked to get out of the way but the man kicked the train powerful to push back the train.
2.in our opinion, the video is fake because the logic that even he is strong enough to kick the train, it should be broken because he kicks not push.
3.in our opinion, they just used CGI to fake the video so it's just a normal man
4.in our opinion, there are 2 clips. one is the train going forward and one clip the man kicking.and they sync and edit the video so it looked like a man kicked and pushed the train.
Names: Sean | 8B - 23
1. I do not have a partner
2. We think that this is definitely not real because it looks very fake and when we slow it down, his foot isn't even touching the train.
3. He is a normal human. He is using editing to change how the video looks like.
4. He is using a green screen to make it look like he is on the train tracks, but in reality, he just put a video of him kicking the air on top of the original video.
1. In the video, the train was coming to the man's direction at a fast speed. But, the man kept standing still and was not avoiding the train and chose to kick it instead.
2. It's not real because none of the humans could have a superpower and it's not logical for a human to kick a train as easy as that.
3. We both think that he is neither a superhero nor a mutant that has no superpower.
4. We think that the footage was made by recording a train that came or moving forward, then they recorded a man kicking, then they reverse the train and they edit it to become one video
By: Beatric 8B/2 and Callysta 8B/3
Names : Gracya 8B/10 and Samantha 8B/22
1. we think in the video there is a man in the rail and there is a train honking and he stand in the middle of the rail and a train showed up and he kick the train so the train moved back.
2.In our opinion it isn’t real i think it is edited by the creator.in our opinion human have no power to do that.
3.we think he is a normal human being and he has a good skill of acting.
4.In our opinion they recorded the video with green screen in a studio and after the recorded the video they edited or we think that they film in the train station but they made two video and than they edited the video
1. from the video, we can see that a train was coming towards and suddenly the man came in. the train was about to crash him, but he kicked the train back easily.
2. we think it is not real because normal human can’t do that thing as easy as that.
3. in our opinion, he is neither superhero or mutant, but maybe he edits and it turns into that video
4. they use editing skills to create that clip. first, they shoot when the train is coming towards. second, the man come in and act like he is kicking the train. third, they shoot when the train goes to the opposite way or maybe they can reverse the first scene.
by : Joyce 8B/15 & Vicka 8B/25
Names : Ameris Suellen 8B/1 and Hanna F. G. 8B/11
1. in the video, we can see there is a man on the railroad line, he looks like he was kicking the train. The train moves back when the man kick it.
2. In our opinion, no it's not real. Because the video was edited. Because we think that there's no human have the power to do that.
3. he's not a superhero or a mutant, but he has great editing skills.
4. first, the videographer took a video of the man pretending to kick something. after that, when the train comes, the videographer took a video of the train. and then we edit the video until the man looks like he kicks the train.
1. The video described a man whom kicked a train so it went the other way
2. No, the video is fake. It is edited
3. No, he is just a normal human
4. They made the video with the train moving it and the person walked up to it and kicked it. And they reverse the footage of the video so it would look like the train is coming towards him and he kicked it.
Addition
Carlson 8b 4 & Neilwin 8b 20
1. In the video, we can see that a train was coming and honking the horn. When the train was crossing the road, there was a man who was crossing and when he saw the train was coming to him, he kicked the train until it moved backward.
2. In our opinion, it's fake. It is impossible. If someone kicks an incoming train, the leg must be badly injured and can even threatened his life and the train is so heavy that it is impossible to kick.
3. in our opinion, the man is not a sulerhero. He is just someone who is good at editing videos.
4. First, record the train that comes across the street. Second, record the person crossing the railroad tracks. Third, record the person while kicking in the middle of the train tracks. Finally, record the train in the opposite direction from the first scene. Then, combine all the videos.
1.The video is about a train about to crash into a man but the man kikced the train really powerful to push back the train
2.My oponion to the video is fake , because its imposibble that a man can punch that powerful
3.Its possible that the man use Adobe Premiere to fake the video
4.one is the train going forward and one clip the man kicking.and they sync and edit the video so it looked like a man kicked and pushed the train.
1. The man who kicked the train to go back in that video was insane and that couldn't be done by normal people. We are sure that this is an edited video.
2. No, because there really isn't any human like that and it's definitely edited. Even if it was real, he woulf surely die.
3.Obviously this is an edited video, but if it isn't then it's likely that person is mutant
4. The video clip can look like that because he makes it look like he's on the camera close to the train. So, that when he kick the train it looks really like a kick. Then, to reverse the train, you can just played again the video.
Our discussion :
So when Shasha and I discussed about this video, we discussed what was happening in the video. Well, when we discuss, there was a little debate because we were still confused about how to do it. However, we finally understood. Then we discuss numbers one to four, finally we can conclude that, The man who kicked the train to go back. We are sure that this is an edited video. Humanely, how could humans who both ate rice, would do crazy things like kicking a train? Of course it's crazy. This video is too extraordinary to be thought through common sense.
By : cathalia 8B/5 and natasha 8B/19
(sir/Teguh)
Great, Eunike & William.
I love your answer #4. Videobeditimg, eh?
(sir/Teguh)
Great, Henri & Willy.
Also, for the revision.
I love your answer #4.
Reversing the footage, eh?
*Video-editing
(sir/Teguh)
Good job, Natania & Chika.
I like your answer #4.
But the man was not really kicking
doing fast/ agile move, eh? Just a video-editing
1.A man got on the rail track while a moving train was approaching dan kicked it away in the opposite direction
2.The video is fake in my opinion, because its no way a person can do that
3.He is just a regular human with some time and special effects to spare
4.He probably recorded the footage of the train separately from himslef. He added and splice himself into the video later using a green screen. He also reversed the footage to make it seem like the train was pushed back by the kick
by Vincent and Matthew
Post a Comment